A brief word of warning for those who own the 2CD edition of Brotherhood:
Your discs may be getting weird white spots! This seems to be the fault of the sleeves they used for them, as the insides are rough.
I purchased a copy of it today and both discs had white spots on the data side. CD1 ripped just fine, although it struggled with Star Guitar. But CD2 wouldn't rip at all!!!
There is a fix: run your discs under water and use dish soap, if needed. Here is a more detailed guide:
https://superuser.com/questions/962981/how-to-clean-cd-dvd-that-have-mold-on-themAfter that, CD2 ripped perfectly and I even went back and re-ripped Star Guitar.